These classic Italian anise cookies are tender, easy, and covered in a glaze with sprinkles. Enjoy these cookies as part of a holiday cookie tray or year-round!
So much of what I love about the holiday season is tied to food (because, obviously), and family favorite recipes dominate my holiday menu each year. Can you relate to that? I try out a few new cookies or side dishes or whatnot each year, but by and large it wouldn’t be Christmas, let’s say, without baked clam dip and struffoli and Panettone french toast.
I already have my clams, honey, and Panettone ready to go. 🙂
Besides struffoli, one of the Italian recipes my mom has made every year since before I can even remember are Italian anise cookies. These tender, licorice-flavored cookies are topped with glaze and festive sprinkles to add a special touch to any holiday cookie tray. I know the licorice flavor can be polarizing like cilantro, but for those who don’t mind or like it – these Italian anise cookies will be just your speed.
In our family recipe we always use anise, though I know others use vanilla, almond, or citrus extracts in place of it. The quantities of anise extract as written in the recipe card below (in my opinion) are just enough – you can certainly taste it, but it’s not in-your-face and overpowering.
When it comes to the flour, you’ll notice I mention to start with three cups. Once all of the cookie ingredients are mixed together, poke the dough and see how it is. Likely it’ll be pretty sticky, so work in additional flour one tablespoon at a time until the stickiness has reduced. You’ll want the dough to be able to roll between your hands with very minimal sticking. I added an extra 1/4-cup during this process, but you may need more or less depending on how your dough is behaving.
Oh! And something else about the flour. My procedure for measuring flour is to first stir/whisk the flour in its canister to fluff it up. Then I spoon it into my measuring cup, taking care not to pack it down. Once the measuring cup is overflowing, I use the straight edge of my spoon to level off the measuring cup. I’ll do that step over top of the flour canister so the excess goes right back in. This way of measuring prevents extra flour from being added to the recipe, which can cause baked goods to be dry. It’s the way I measure flour for all my recipes.
MAKE-AHEAD TIP: These Italian anise cookies can be made several days ahead of time. If doing so, I suggest baking the cookies and then NOT glazing them until the day you would like to serve them. Reason being is that the next day and the days beyond, the colors of the rainbow nonpareils bleed onto the white glaze and don’t look quite as picture perfect as they day they were glazed and decorated. Of course if you don’t really care about that feel free to glaze ’em up right away, or you can omit the sprinkles or use white nonpareils instead.
These classic Italian anise cookies are tender, easy, and covered in a glaze with sprinkles. Enjoy these cookies as part of a holiday cookie tray or year-round!
- 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened
- 1/2 cup granulated sugar
- 3 eggs
- 1/4 cup milk (I used 2%, use your preferred)
- 2 tsp anise extract
- 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
- 3 1/4 cups all-purpose flour, start at 3 [see instructions]
- 1 tbsp baking powder
- 2 cups confectioners' sugar
- 3 tbsp water
- 1/4 tsp anise extract
- Nonpareils for decoration
-
Preheat oven to 350°F. Line two large baking sheets with parchment paper and set aside.
-
Cream butter and sugar together in a large mixing bowl for a few minutes until smooth and creamy.
-
Add the eggs and beat well using a hand or stand mixer, until the mixture is light and looks frothy.
-
Add milk, anise extract, and vanilla extract and mix until combined.
-
Add 3 cups of flour and baking powder to a separate bowl and whisk until evenly combined.
-
In 2-3 increments, add flour mixture to the bowl with the wet ingredients, mixing in until just combined.
-
Add additional flour as needed, 1 tbsp at a time, until you can roll a cookie's worth of dough between your palms with minimal sticking. I added 1/4 cup (4 tbsp) during this time, bringing the total flour used to 3 1/4 cup. The amount of flour you need may vary.
-
Using a 1 1/2-tbsp cookie scoop, scoop balls of dough and roll between your palms to form spheres. Some of the dough will stick inside the scoop but that's okay. Place dough balls equally-spaced on the baking sheets, leaving about 1 1/2 inches between one another.
-
Bake for 10-12 minutes, or until cookies are very lightly brown on the bottom. Transfer to a rack to cool completely.
-
Once cookies have cooled completely, whisk together 2 cups confectioners' sugar, 3 tbsp water, and 1/4 tsp anise extract. Dip the tops of each anise cookie into the glaze, and then sprinkle nonpareils over top. Let glaze harden completely before storing.
Karen Bragg says
What time of year would stores have these cookies? I love ❤️ them but am thinking I would end up eating them all since my husband is not a fan. I ALWAYS buy them when I see them in the store but it is usually hit or miss.
Alyssa says
Hi Karen, I know what you mean! I’m thinking you might be able to find them again in stores around Easter time, so I’d look around April. Hopefully that does the trick!
Joe says
My wife doesn’t like them either so today I’m substituting almond
Kathy says
Why after a few days do mine get so dry?
Alyssa says
Hi Kathy, how are you storing them? Once completely cooled and the glaze hardened, I keep them in an air-tight container or sealable plastic bag with parchment paper between the layers to prevent the glaze from becoming messed up. I haven’t experienced any drying that way. I hope that is helpful!
Linda says
Can you put anise cookies back in oven if they are under cooked aftet they cooled
Alyssa says
Hi Linda, yup! If they haven’t been glazed yet they can go back in until cooked through.
Jano says
These were so easy & delicious! They impressed my Italian friend whose mother always made these. It was a hard act to follow but they were perfect!
Alyssa says
Now that’s a compliment! So glad you liked them, Jano. 🙂
Nicole says
I just made a big batch of these but I did not have anise so I used vanilla extract thinking that would work but when I bit into a cookie it had a bitter taste. Is it because I didn’t use the anise extract? I’m so mad because they came out so pretty and baked well ☹️
Alyssa says
Hi Nicole, I’m sorry you had some trouble with these. Anise extract has a bold presence, so using vanilla for all of the extract could have thrown off the balance of flavors. I’ve never made them without the anise but that would be my guess. Could you improvise with the glaze? It’s sweet, but perhaps add an extract or another flavor to it to counteract the bitterness? There’s always a melted chocolate dip or drizzle – a method I use to bump up flavor/sweetness on a baked good. I hope that is helpful!
Ron Foley says
Perfect recipe! The only thing I add is 15oz of ricotta cheese. 🙂
Alyssa says
Yum! Glad you like it, Ron!
Sarah says
I’ve gotten so many compliments about these cookies! They’re a hit. My hubs said they’re better than the store bought ones!
Thank you!
Alyssa says
Awesome! Glad they’re a hit, Sarah! 🙂
Jori says
I watched my mother and aunts make anise cookies for years. I then made them for years. I was never happy with them so this year I looked for a new recipe. This recipe is hands down, no contest the best. I could not believe how good they were. **********
Alyssa says
Woohoo! Love hearing that. So glad you like them, Jori!
Pam says
Can these cookies be made in a cookie bar format or bunt cake form
Alyssa says
Hi Pam, I haven’t made them any way other than rolling them into balls so I’m not sure. I’d be afraid the consistency of the cookie part would be off.
Shelly says
Can almond milk be used?
Alyssa says
That should work just fine!
Susita says
Can’t wait to try these–my italian grandmother used to make these. They were a Christmas staple in her house. I love them!!
Alyssa says
Hope you enjoy, Susita! Gotta love family traditions. 🙂
Susita says
I just made these cookies today. They are AMAZING! The best recipe and also the most like my grandmothers I have ever had. I ate half the batch by myself and will be baking more later this week. I thank you. My waistline, however, doesn’t thank you.
Alyssa says
I’m so happy to hear that! I’m planning to bake them a few times this season because I know they’ll go quickly once they’re done. 🙂
Deanna says
I love making these for cookie trays! Plus we have this tradition in Pittsburgh called cookie table for weddings. These would be perfect on a cookie table!
Alyssa says
You know, I have never heard of a cookie table! What a fun (and delicious) wedding tradition. 🙂
Sandra says
went to a wedding and she had each couple bring one batch of homemade cookies with the recipe and a note from them. She put them on a table and as the guests were leaving, they could fill up a Chinese to go box with cookies. Everyone loved the idea!!!
Brandi says
These cookies look almost too good to eat. I need to make these soon!
Amy Nash says
These are such cute little cookies with the sprinkles! I actually just tried Italian anise cookies this past Christmas and fell in love! It’s such a unique, distinctive flavor! Thanks for sharing your recipe so I can make these at home!
Kathy says
A very delicious and easy version of this cookie. I made them for Christmas. Thank you.
Alyssa says
Glad you liked them, Kathy! Merry Christmas. 🙂
Shanna says
These sound delicious. I have anise seed that I sometimes grind to a powder using my mortar and pestle, but I’ve never seen anise extract. Where do you find it?
Alyssa says
Hi Shanna, I’ve found anise extract alongside the vanilla and almond extracts in the baking aisle. Earlier this month I went looking for it in a smaller specialty grocery chain but they didn’t carry it, so I’m thinking larger chains (or online) would be the way to go. I’ve never worked with ground anise seed before, but I would imagine you could use that instead of the extract for the dough (and maybe the icing if it’s powdery enough?). I’m just not sure what the extract-to-powder substitution ratio would be. Please let me know if you give them a try! 🙂
Steph says
Anise flavorings are found In the flavorings/spices section of your local grocery. The bottles are under “McCormick” brand next to Peppermint, Cherry, Vanilla, etc.