Hummus Avocado Turkey Club Sandwich

This twist on a turkey club sandwich features the traditional club sandwich components but with creamy mashed avocado and hummus in place of the mayonnaise. This stacked sandwich is sure to brighten up your lunchtime!

As an adult I cannot get enough of a fancy sandwich, but I went through a big please-no-sandwiches-in-my-lunch-box phase when I was in elementary school. For a good portion of a year my mom packed a tupperware container of homemade tortellini salad for the main part of my lunch.

My love for tortellini salad still runs deep, but I'll save that recipe for another post. Today is alllllll about this gussied up and modern turkey club sandwich.

What is a Club Sandwich?

A club, or "clubhouse" sandwich typically contains six main components: bread, cold cuts (usually chicken or turkey), lettuce, tomato, bacon, and mayonnaise.

Its classic look features three slices of bread, making it one tall, substantial sandwich. Because of this extra heft, it's popular to find one club sandwich speared with toothpicks and sliced into quarters, yielding four serious business sections.

In my experience two quarters makes a sufficient lunch serving, so one sandwich, as seen in the photo above, yields two meals.

Recipe Ingredients

Since plain mayo is rarely something I reach for when making myself a sandwich (chipotle aioli is a totally different story), I took the liberty of replacing it here for two fun and still super creamy substitutions: hummus and mashed avocado.

As for the hummus, your favorite store-bought variety will certainly work, though if your food processor needs a little exercise this roasted garlic hummus is a household favorite. Garlic adds a wonderfully complementary flavor to this relatively basic flavor profile.

If you're new to the world of roasted garlic, that's not a typo in the linked hummus recipe. It's two whole heads (!) and not cloves. Roasting significantly mellows the sharp raw garlic flavor, almost caramelizing it in the process. Highly recommend.

We're sticking with turkey here for the cold cuts, as well as crispy bacon. A thick beefsteak tomato is my pick to get those hearty sandwich slices.

As for the bread and lettuce, I'm partial to green leaf over iceberg and multigrain bread over white, but that's just my personal preference. Any kind you like will work.

Recipe Steps and Helpful Hints

While assembling a sandwich definitely doesn't need to be precise, there are a few tips along the way to make the process easier. And less messy.

First you'll want to cook your bacon in your preferred manner: oven, stovetop, air fryer, etc. Bacon on the crispy side is my go-to. Next toast three slices of bread, as toasting helps prevent them from becoming soggy from the hummus and avocado.

As for the assembly process, start with a piece of bread spread with hummus. About one tablespoon will do the trick. Next add a layer of lettuce, then two thin-ish tomato slices. Season those with salt and pepper. Add the bacon slices on top, then the turkey.

Then take the second piece of bread and spread both sides of it with mashed avocado. Place that on top of the turkey (it may be easier to spread the second side once it's already on the sandwich.

Now start the process again: lettuce, tomato, bacon, and turkey. Spread one side of the last slice of bread with hummus to cap off this large and in charge modern turkey club sandwich.

It's inevitable that a sandwich this large can get a little messy. To help hold things together, you can spear four areas of the sandwich with toothpicks, if you're slicing into four quarters. You'll want to cut The sandwich diagonally both ways like you're making an "X" on the top.

More Sandwich Recipes

If you’ve enjoyed this recipe, I’d love for you to leave a star rating in the recipe card and/or a comment review below!

P.S. The images and post content here are a total redo the original post. If you're coming back via Pinterest or a saved link, you might recognize what this recipe originally looked like, below. Same great recipe, just with improved pictures!