Enjoy rainbow cookies (or tricolor cookies, or seven layer cookies) for Easter with these Chocolate-Covered Easter Egg Rainbow Cookies! The classic dessert of spongy almond layers and raspberry jam is updated with spring colors, egg shapes, and Easter egg decorations.
Hi, my name is Alyssa, and I’m a rainbow cookie addict. Hands down these have been my favorite cookie since as far back as I can remember. For a few consecutive birthdays when I was younger, I would have a giant rainbow cookie as my cake. This always seemed like a humongous feat for a bakery to accomplish. “Wow, a WHOLE cake!”, but looking back now, it probably saved them a step or two as they made their standard rainbow cookie recipe but didn’t have to slice them up. Either way, I relished the opportunity to savor as much of my favorite cookie as I could.
Which even meant eating a slice for breakfast the next morning, because you’re allowed to do that on the day after your birthday, right? Yes. And I think the same goes for Easter, but don’t quote me on that.
Speaking of Easter, I would absolutely love it if the Easter Bunny dropped these babies off in his yearly travels. I must admit that while I was a rainbow cookie freak when I was little, I was not a fan of the Easter Bunny. At all. Yes, I loved the delicious treats he would bring, but bordering-on-neurotic little me had a panic one year on the night before Easter. I was in despair trying to reconcile in my head how a large bunny was able to infiltrate locked doors and windows and get into my house. I didn’t know of a magical entrance he would use, a la Santa, so wouldn’t any old person be able to break in, too?
Can you say “over-thinker” from day one? My poor parents.
Anyway, Mr. Bunny left me a sweet letter that year, assuring me that he was a happy bunny who meant no harm, my house was secure, etc. What a stand up rabbit! His words (and chocolates) were good enough for me, though it wouldn’t have hurt if he threw in a few of these chocolate-covered delights to sweeten the deal.
If you’ve never enjoyed a rainbow cookie before, a) I’m so sorry and b) let me tell you about them. These three-layer cookies are traditionally shaped like little blocks (see above) and colored red, white, and green. The layers are spongy and moist, with an almond flavoring thanks to the addition of both almond paste and extract, with jam (either apricot or raspberry) pressed in between each layer. The cookies are then topped with chocolate. Bada bing, bada boom, I’ll take five please.
These Easter egg rainbow cookies use a standard rainbow cookie recipe, but the festive pizzazz is brought courtesy of using different food colorings and an oval-shaped cookie cutter. They do take a degree of planning ahead and prep time, but the final output is well worth the effort. The pan of cookies, pre-slicing, needs to be refrigerated for at least eight hours, so I recommend preparing the cookie layers the night before and letting them chill overnight. Plus when you’re asleep, you’re (hopefully) not pacing back and forth in front of the refrigerator waiting for them to be ready.
Recipe Notes:
- Since these Easter egg rainbow cookies are dense, you’ll likely want to use a cookie cutter on the smaller size. I couldn’t find a small, oval cookie cutter locally and didn’t feel like ordering one, so I bent a small circular cookie cutter into an oval shape. Works! 😂
- Once the cookie layers are assembled with raspberry jam between them, parchment paper and then something weighty, like another baking sheet, goes over top while the bars sit in the refrigerator. This helps the three layers stick together, so they won’t separate when you cut them.
- Since there are different types of food coloring available (liquid, gel, etc.), I didn’t specify how many drops of each color should be used. I used liquid food coloring, and went in increments of five drops at a time and stirring to see how the colors were looking. Use enough to reach your desired coloring.
Ingredients
- 4 eggs separated
- 1 cup granulated sugar
- 1 7- or 8-oz container almond paste [see note]
- 1 1/4 cups unsalted butter softened
- 1 tsp almond extract
- 2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1/2 tsp salt
- Red food coloring for pink layer
- Red & blue food coloring for purple layer
- Yellow food coloring for yellow layer
- 1/2 cup seedless raspberry jam
- 10 oz dark chocolate chopped
- Melted white chocolate for piping
- Sprinkles for decoration optional
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350°F. Grease a 9" x 13" rectangular pan, then press parchment paper to bottom of pan, leaving enough excess paper sticking up along the 9" sides so that you can lift each cookie layer by them after baking. Grease top side of parchment paper, and set pan aside.
- Beat egg whites on medium-high speed using a stand or hand mixer for several minutes until peaks form. Gradually add 1/4 cup of the sugar to the egg whites until mixture holds stiff peaks, approximately 2-3 minutes. Pour egg white mixture into another bowl and tidy up mixing bowl to be used again.
- Add almond paste to the now-empty bowl and remaining 3/4 cup sugar and mix on medium speed until almond paste is broken up and both ingredients are well integrated. Add butter and mix for a few minutes until light and creamy. Pour in egg yolks and almond extract and mix for another few minutes. Lower mixer speed to low and add flour and salt. Beat until dry ingredients are just mixed in.
- Pour half of egg white mixture into butter mixture and fold in. Repeat with remaining half of egg white mixture.
- Separate dough into three bowls - one for each colored layer. Stir red food coloring into one (to make pink), equal red and blue food coloring into the second (to make the purple layer), and yellow food coloring into the third.
- Spread dough from one of the bowls into the prepared baking pan and smooth top (batter will be very thin). The batter does not need to reach the edges of the pan - just to form an even, thin layer.
- Bake for 8-10 minutes, until batter has set and a toothpick in the center comes out clean. Using the excess parchment paper sticking out from beneath the cookie layer, lift layer out of pan and place on wire rack to cool.
- Press new parchment paper to bottom, leaving excess as before. Bake next layer in the same manner as the first. Once done, repeat steps with remaining layer.
- Heat raspberry jam slightly in microwave and stir.
- Once all layers have cooled, heat raspberry jam slightly in the microwave so that it's a bit thinner and easy to spread.
- Invert pink layer onto a sheet of parchment paper, and peel off parchment paper that used to be on the bottom of the layer. Spread half of raspberry jam evenly over pink layer, then invert yellow layer on top. Peel parchment paper from top side and evenly spread second half of raspberry jam over layer. Invert purple layer on top and peel off parchment paper. Place a new layer of parchment paper over top of purple layer, and wrap cookie layers with plastic wrap. Place a baking sheet on top of cookie layers to weigh them down and refrigerate overnight, or at least eight hours.
- Once cookie layers have chilled, remove from refrigerator.
For egg-shaped cookies:
- Press oval cookie cutter into the cookie layers and place oval cookies onto wire rack (see note). Melt dark chocolate in bowl in microwave for 15 second intervals, stirring after each interval until chocolate is fluid. Place to top of each egg-shaped cookie in chocolate to form a top chocolate layer. Place each cookie back on wire rack to harden. Once chocolate has hardened, melt white chocolate and pipe Easter egg decorations (such as the squiggles I did) on top of chocolate-covered egg cookies. Let harden, then serve.
Notes
Nutritional information is provided as an estimate. As it can vary due to many factors (brands used, quantities, etc.), we cannot guarantee its accuracy.
Recipe adapted from the Food Network
Photos in this post were updated March 2017.
Kristi @ Inspiration Kitchen says
Gahhhhhhh!!! Ok, my sistah. Two things. (1) How do I get these in my life, right now??? and (2) How in the world did I miss this post??? I just subscribed because I can’t stand one more minute of missing your FABulous posts. Oh, and these cookies. I definitely need these cookies right now. 🙂 Pinned! Because I’ve never, ever, ever heard of them before either!
Alyssa says
Thanks, Kristi! So glad to introduce you to my beloved rainbow cookies!! Just like you introduced me to that crazy (…crazy AWESOME) xango! These take some work so unfortunately they’re not great for instant gratification 🙁 but the recipe yields a BUNCH and they’re well worth the wait! I’m still hoarding a few in the freezer hehe
Mademoiselle Gourmande says
Wow, they look great! I hope I can still make them in time for sunday… 🙂 Thank you for sharing! 🙂
Alyssa says
Thank you so much! 🙂
Chelsea @chelseasmessyapron says
These are so gorgeous Alyssa! What a wonderfully creative idea! Perfect for Easter! Pinned 🙂
Alyssa says
Thanks Chelsea! I’ll take any excuse I can to make them. Easter dessert? Perfect! And thanks for the pin!. 🙂
Monica says
Oh my gosh! Alyssa, I’m reading your most recent post when I saw you refer to rainbow cookies. They are one of our very favorites at my house, too!! Totally divine but I see you already know that! : ) Anyway…I made a rainbow (I call them “tri-color”) cookie CAKE recently with a loose Easter theme and I’ll be posting it tomorrow. The colors didn’t really work out…I also wanted to go for lavender but couldn’t work it out so I stuck to the basis…but the cool thing is it’s a cake! I make the cookies mostly at Christmas and I’ve turned them into mini cupcakes before but now I saw this cake recipe, tried it, and it was awesome. Your Easter egg version is so creative. I just LOVE it. Great job! Can I have a dozen? ; )
Alyssa says
Yes! Other rainbow cookie fanatics! Monica, that cake sounds AMAZING, I can’t wait to check it out. And mini cupcakes? Swoon. These cookies are a labor of love, as you know, but so, SO worth the outcome. I really appreciate the time that goes into making them now that I live in an area where they’re a lot less prevalent. Such a special treat! 🙂
Ashley @ My Midwest Table says
I’ve never had Rainbow Cookies, but I’ve seen them several times and am always curious about them. I think this pastel version is so pretty. It would definitely be perfect on an Easter dessert table…if they make it that far. 🙂
Alyssa says
If they make it that far – so true! I shuffled off a fair amount of this batch to the freezer before we could do serious damage! I’m already envisioning holiday colors galore with this recipe…just gives me more excuses to make them. 🙂
Erin | The Law Student's Wife says
I would absolutely positively take an Easter basket filled
with these pretty spring cookies. They are absolutely gorgeous, and I am sure they taste even better!
Alyssa says
Thank you, Erin! I’m pretty sure I’m going to make another batch of these and fill up my own Easter basket this year. 🙂
Consuelo @ Honey & Figs says
I never knew such cookies existed but now I know that I won’t be able to live without them! They look fabulous oh MY MY MY I want two dozens pronto
Alyssa says
Rainbow cookies must be in your future, Consuelo! They are so amazing I think everyone should experience them at least once. Another thing I love about the recipe is that it yields so many cookies, so both my stomach and my freezer are full of them. A win-win. 🙂
Helen @ Scrummy Lane says
I am SUPER impressed that you made these, Alyssa! I’ve never heard of them but they’re so pretty and would make a wonderful gift! 🙂
Alyssa says
Thank you, Helen! I’ll take any excuse to make them. Pretty colors for the Easter dessert table? No problem!
Pamela @ Brooklyn Farm Girl says
Love the layer of color in these delicious cookies!
Alyssa says
Thanks! 🙂
Chris @ Shared Appetite says
Oh my gosh… I’m obsessed with rainbow cookies!! Like, Asheley has to DRAG me away from bakeries so I don’t completely wipe them out of their rainbow cookie inventory. I love them so much. SO MUCH! You just made me incredibly happy with this post, hahaha
Alyssa says
Haha thanks Chris! I so feel the same way. Anytime we’d pick up a pound of cookies from a bakery for a family gathering when I was younger, I’d make sure my parents knew to *please* ask for the highest ratio of rainbows-to-other cookies as the bakery could do!
Cindy @ Pick Fresh Foods says
Would you believe I have never had rainbow cake or cookies? Sounds and looks delicious! These are so cute! I love how you shaped them into eggs. Very creative 😀
Alyssa says
Thanks, Cindy! I’ll take any excuse to make/eat them, so out came the Easter cookie cutter. 🙂
Aunt. B says
Overnight shipping would be great. You do provide samples???????
Alyssa says
Of course, Aunt B! 😉
Natalie @ Tastes Lovely says
How have I never heard of rainbow cookies? These sound amazing! Perfect for easter : )
Alyssa says
Thanks Natalie! And they are fabulous, for sure. 🙂
whatjessicabakednext says
These look delicious! Perfect recipe for Easter!
Alyssa says
Thanks Jessica!